SEO

Google AI Mode Study: Fewer Clicks, What Local SEO Does

By ·

Google AI Mode Study: Fewer Clicks, What Local SEO Does

A new preprint from researchers at the University of Pennsylvania and Northeastern University put numbers on something many website owners already suspect: when searchers are pushed into Google’s AI Mode, fewer of them click through to websites. In the experiment, people forced into AI Mode clicked out to external sites 18.8 percentage points less often than people using ordinary Google. For a local business that depends on enquiries from its website, that is worth understanding, but it is also easy to over-read. Here is what the study did, what it did not do, and a calm plan for your own local SEO.

What the study found

The paper, “AI in Search Reduces Publisher Referrals Without Improving User Experience”, was covered by PPC Land. It is a preregistered randomised field experiment. A Chrome extension logged searches and clicks for a three-day baseline, then participants were randomly placed for seven days in one of three conditions: AI Overviews hidden, normal Google, or all searches forced into AI Mode. Recruitment ran in March 2026, and 1,100 people made up the behavioural sample.

The headline results, compared with normal Google users:

  • Click-through to outside websites was 18.8 points lower for the AI Mode group (14.9 points lower if each AI Mode conversation counts as one search).
  • Clicks on news sites were 12.5 points lower, and on Reddit 21.2 points lower.
  • Ad clicks were 42.7 points lower, although the authors say AI Mode showed no ads at the time of the study.
  • Use of Bing, DuckDuckGo or Yahoo rose by 11.2 points.
  • Participants rated trust and usefulness of Google lower.

PPC Land also points to an earlier randomised study by Saharsh Agarwal and Ananya Sen, of the Indian School of Business and Carnegie Mellon, which found AI Overviews reduced outbound organic clicks by 39.8%.

Why you should not panic

The same coverage lists real limits, and a careful owner should read them. The study ran for only seven days, and use was forced rather than chosen. AI Mode accounted for just 0.6% of searches before the study, so the switch was abrupt for participants. The sample skewed younger and more educated than the US population, and only desktop Chrome users were studied, not mobile apps. The paper is a preprint and has not been peer reviewed. The authors also note that click data alone does not show whether the clicks that remain are of higher quality.

Most important for you: this was a US experiment. We do not have a figure for how Indian users behave in AI Mode, and we will not invent one. Many local searches in Bengaluru or Darbhanga happen on mobile, in Maps, or by phone number lookup, which this study did not measure.

What it means for a local business

Treat the study as a reason to stop relying on a single path. If some searchers get an answer without clicking, the places where your business shows up inside Google matter more: your Business Profile, your reviews, your photos, your hours, and the calls, direction requests and messages those produce. We saw related changes recently when AI Overview local packs dropped action buttons. The pattern is consistent: customers may decide before they ever reach your site.

That does not make your website unimportant. It means your site and your profile must say the same true things, and your reporting must measure more than website visits.

Local SEO · FSK Digital Marketing

Monthly Local SEO Management

Local SEO that works for you every single day.

From ₹15,000 / month

Buy now

A six-step plan for this month

  1. Separate your numbers. In Google Business Profile performance, note calls, direction requests, website clicks and messages each month. Do not judge success from website clicks alone.
  2. Check Search Console trends carefully. Look at impressions and clicks for your main service pages over several weeks, not a single day. Core updates and AI changes can overlap, so avoid blaming one cause.
  3. Make your profile answer the first question. Services, hours, price hints, service areas and photos should answer what a customer asks before they call.
  4. Keep review replies and new reviews moving. Ask real customers for honest reviews and reply to existing ones. Never buy or fake reviews.
  5. Give every page one clear action. A call button, WhatsApp link or booking form near the top. If fewer people click through, make each visit count.
  6. Track enquiry source. Ask every new customer “how did you find us?” and write the answer down. It beats guessing.

How to read a study like this

When a headline number appears, ask three questions before changing your plans. Who was studied, and do they look like your customers? How long did it last, and was the behaviour chosen or forced? And what was measured: clicks, or actual enquiries and sales? This study answers only the first kind of question for a young, US, desktop audience over one week. It is useful evidence that AI answers can reduce referrals, but it is not a forecast for your clinic, shop or coaching centre. The best evidence for your business is your own record of calls, messages and visits, kept consistently month after month.

Meanwhile, other engines are testing web-only views

Interestingly, the same week brought signs that not everyone wants AI-only answers. Search Engine Roundtable reported that Bing is testing a “Web Mode” tab showing only web page results, without AI Overviews or Copilot answers, though it did not appear fully live. A second report says ChatGPT is testing web-only results and a “See more” button under AI answers, and the author could not reproduce those tests himself. These are experiments, and may change or vanish. The sensible reading is simply that search layouts are in flux, which is another reason to keep your business information correct everywhere customers might look, including Bing and other directories.

How FSK approaches it

We do not promise rankings or traffic, and nobody honestly can in a period of this much change. What we do is routine work that holds up whichever interface Google shows: profile accuracy, local page content, review handling and clean monthly reporting. Our monthly local SEO management starts at ₹15,000 a month and covers that cycle. If your profile is the weak spot, start with Google Business Profile optimization from ₹4,999. For context on how we measure shifts, see our guide to measuring local impact of a core update.

Frequently asked questions

Does this study prove AI Mode will cut my website traffic?

No. It shows that when 1,100 US users were forced into AI Mode for a week, their clicks to outside sites fell. It is a preprint, short, desktop-only and not specific to India. Watch your own data instead of assuming.

Should I stop investing in my website?

No. Your website still supports your profile, your ads and your brand searches. It should work together with your Business Profile rather than being your only channel.

What is the single best first step?

Record this month’s calls, direction requests, messages and website clicks side by side. Without a baseline you cannot tell whether any change is real.

The takeaway is steady, not dramatic: make sure customers can choose you from wherever they see you. If you would like a second pair of eyes on your numbers, talk to FSK.

Local SEO · FSK Digital Marketing

Monthly Local SEO Management

Local SEO that works for you every single day.

From ₹15,000 / month

Buy now

Sources